Incoterms Explained: Who Pays for Shipping and Who Bears the Risk of Loss
We once reviewed a China manufacturing contract that required the factory to ship goods FOB (Free on Board) but also said the factory would bear the risk of loss until the American buyer received, inspected, and accepted them at its warehouse. The buyer thought it had negotiated extra protection. Instead, the contract contained two provisions that allocated risk differently, without explaining which controlled. The parties were free to negotiate a departure from standard FOB terms, but they needed to make that departure clear. Otherwise, a damaged shipment turns into an expensive fight over the meaning of the contract.
We see variations of this problem regularly. Companies spend weeks negotiating product specifications and prices, then accept whatever three-letter shipping term appears on the factory's quotation. Nobody pays much attention until a container is lost or damaged and the buyer discovers that its insurance does not cover the loss. By then, the shipping term that barely merited a discussion during negotiations has become the center of the dispute.
What Incoterms Are and What They Decide
Incoterms (International Commercial Terms) are standardized rules for international shipping, published by the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC), which first introduced them in 1936. The current edition, Incoterms 2020, contains 11 rules used by manufacturers, importers, exporters, and freight forwarders throughout the world. Incoterms establish who arranges transportation, who pays for freight, who handles export and import clearance, and when the buyer assumes the risk if goods are stolen, damaged, or destroyed. The rules become part of a transaction when the parties incorporate them into their agreement. They do not automatically apply to every international sale, and they do not replace the manufacturing or sales contract. A company can enter into a valid international sales contract without specifying an Incoterm, but it then needs to establish delivery obligations and risk allocation through other contractual provisions and applicable law.
Too many companies treat Incoterms primarily as pricing terms. A buyer compares an EXW quotation with an FOB quotation and chooses the lower number without accounting for the additional transportation obligations, and then pays for losses it never anticipated. The ICC publishes a free Incoterms 2020 Checklist and Flowcharts that we recommend to companies regularly purchasing products overseas.
The 11 Incoterms and Where Risk Passes
Seven Incoterms can be used for any mode of transportation, including shipments that combine trucks, trains, aircraft, and vessels. Four are intended specifically for sea and inland waterway transportation. The following table identifies the principal risk-transfer point under each rule and its most important practical consideration.
| Incoterm | When Risk Generally Transfers | Main Practical Consideration |
|---|---|---|
| EXW (Ex Works) | When goods are made available at the agreed location, before loading | Buyer generally handles loading, transportation, and export clearance |
| FCA (Free Carrier) | When goods are delivered to the buyer's nominated carrier at the agreed point | Often preferable when the buyer controls shipping |
| CPT (Carriage Paid To) | When goods are handed over to the carrier, generally the first carrier | Seller pays transportation to the named destination, although risk transfers earlier |
| CIP (Carriage and Insurance Paid To) | When goods are handed over to the carrier, generally the first carrier | Seller pays freight and obtains specified cargo insurance |
| DAP (Delivered at Place) | At the named destination, ready for unloading | Seller bears transportation risk to destination; buyer handles import clearance |
| DPU (Delivered at Place Unloaded) | After unloading at the named destination | Seller bears responsibility for unloading |
| DDP (Delivered Duty Paid) | At the named destination, ready for unloading | Seller handles import clearance and contractually assumes import duties |
| FAS (Free Alongside Ship) | When goods are placed alongside the vessel | Sea and inland waterway only, and not a term we focus on for China container shipments |
| FOB (Free on Board) | When goods are aboard the vessel | Frequently unsuitable for containerized shipments |
| CFR (Cost and Freight) | When goods are aboard the vessel | Seller pays ocean freight, but buyer bears risk during the voyage |
| CIF (Cost, Insurance and Freight) | When goods are aboard the vessel | Seller pays ocean freight and obtains specified insurance |
Under CPT, CIP, CFR, and CIF, the seller pays for transportation to an agreed destination even though the risk generally passes to the buyer much earlier. Under DAP, the seller ordinarily bears transportation risk until the goods reach the named destination, even though the buyer handles import clearance. For companies purchasing containerized products from China, the terms we pay closest attention to are FOB, FCA, EXW, CPT, CIP, CIF, and DDP.
Why FOB Is Often a Bad Choice for China Manufacturing
In 2022, we published an article called International Shipping Terms and Why FOB Is So DEADLY, which remains available through Lexology. We went so far as to tell readers to eliminate FOB from their international shipping vocabulary. That was too broad because FOB remains appropriate for certain bulk commodities and other cargo loaded directly onto vessels. But our concern about using FOB for ordinary container shipments was well founded, and it remains relevant to companies buying manufactured products from China.
Consider what happens to a container after a Chinese factory finishes production. The factory packs the goods, loads the container onto a truck, and sends it to the port. The container may spend several days at a terminal before being loaded aboard a vessel bound for the United States. During that period, a truck accident, theft, fire, or mishandling can damage or destroy the shipment. Under FOB Incoterms 2020, the Chinese factory generally bears the risk of physical loss or damage until the goods are loaded aboard the vessel. The buyer assumes that risk afterward.
In our experience, Chinese factories frequently do not carry cargo insurance covering the period between the factory and the ship. They assume the foreign buyer has insured the goods, while the buyer assumes the factory has insurance because it still bears the contractual risk. The mistake becomes especially expensive when the buyer has already paid for the products. If the goods are destroyed before loading, the buyer may have a valid contractual claim against the factory but no insurance proceeds available to cover the loss. When the factory refuses to replace the shipment or lacks the money to do so, the buyer faces the prospect of pursuing recovery through litigation or arbitration in China.
The Tianjin Port Explosions
On August 12, 2015, massive explosions devastated part of the Port of Tianjin in China. Thousands of vehicles were damaged or destroyed, shipping containers were burned, and businesses suffered enormous losses. In March 2016, Insurance Journal reported that Swiss Re estimated insured losses from the explosions at between $2.5 billion and $3.5 billion. For a container sitting at the terminal awaiting loading, the consequences depended in part on the contractual shipping terms. If a factory had completed production, received payment, and transported the goods to the port without loading them aboard the vessel, an ordinary FOB arrangement would generally leave the risk of physical loss with the factory. But that contractual responsibility would not guarantee recovery. We have spent enough time pursuing claims against overseas companies to know that establishing who is legally responsible for a loss is only part of the problem, and that getting paid can be considerably harder.
Why FCA Is Usually Better Than FOB for Container Shipments
For most containerized shipments from China, we prefer FCA (Free Carrier) when the buyer arranges international transportation. The ICC reaches essentially the same conclusion in its guidance on shipping containers through ports, identifying FCA, CPT, and CIP as better choices than traditional maritime terms for many container shipments. Containers are ordinarily handed over to a terminal or carrier before being loaded aboard a vessel. FOB ties delivery and risk transfer to the later event of loading aboard the ship. FCA allows the parties to select a delivery point that corresponds to the actual transportation arrangements. Under FCA at the factory, the Chinese seller completes delivery by loading the goods onto the collecting vehicle provided by the buyer's nominated carrier. Risk transfers at that point, allowing the buyer to arrange transportation and cargo insurance beginning with that handover.
FCA can also designate a container terminal as the delivery point. The seller then transports the goods to the agreed terminal and completes delivery when the goods are placed at the disposal of the buyer's nominated carrier on the seller's arriving vehicle, ready for unloading. The seller bears the risk for a longer period than it would under FCA at the factory. A buyer with an experienced freight forwarder may prefer to take responsibility at the factory, while another buyer may want the supplier to handle transportation to the port. The contract should reflect that choice, and the insurance should begin when the buyer assumes the risk.
Companies using letters of credit need to address an additional complication. Banks frequently require an on-board bill of lading, but under FCA the seller completes delivery before the goods are loaded aboard the vessel. That can leave the seller unable to produce the document required for payment. Incoterms 2020 addresses this through an option under FCA A6/B6. If the parties agree to use it, the buyer instructs its carrier to issue an on-board bill of lading to the seller after loading. The seller then tenders that document to the buyer, usually through the banks. The ICC explains the arrangement in its discussion of changes from Incoterms 2010 to Incoterms 2020. The arrangement does not guarantee that the carrier will issue the document, so the contract and letter-of-credit requirements must account for that possibility.
EXW, CPT, CIP, and CIF: Export Clearance, Freight, and Insurance
EXW: A Low Factory Price Can Be Expensive
EXW (Ex Works) imposes relatively few delivery obligations on the manufacturer. The seller makes the goods available at the agreed location, usually its factory, while the buyer generally handles loading, transportation, and export clearance. A lower EXW price looks like the better deal until the buyer adds loading charges, inland transportation, and export procedures, and the difference can disappear. More seriously, the buyer has accepted responsibilities in China that it often has no practical ability to perform.
Export clearance is a common problem. Under EXW, the buyer ordinarily handles export formalities, even though a foreign buyer may have no Chinese company, employees, or authority to carry them out. If the buyer has not arranged for a properly authorized party to handle the export declaration, its freight forwarder may be unable to move the goods out of China. The factory can point to EXW and refuse to take responsibility. The buyer has already paid for products that cannot leave the country until the export-clearance problem is resolved. FCA at the factory generally provides a cleaner arrangement because the seller handles export clearance and loads the goods onto the collecting vehicle, while the buyer controls subsequent transportation. EXW has legitimate uses, particularly when the buyer has its own local logistics arrangements, but a lower factory price is a poor reason to choose it.
CPT, CIP, and CIF: The Freight Bill and the Risk of Loss
Sometimes the seller has better freight rates or more reliable relationships with international carriers. Under CPT, the seller arranges and pays for transportation to the agreed destination, but risk generally transfers when the goods are handed over to the first carrier. Under CIP, the seller assumes similar transportation obligations and must also purchase specified cargo insurance for the buyer's benefit. CIP ordinarily requires coverage equivalent to Institute Cargo Clauses (A) under Incoterms 2020. This is broader than the minimum insurance coverage required under CIF, which generally requires Institute Cargo Clauses (C) coverage unless the parties agree otherwise. The distinction matters when cargo is damaged by something outside the narrower list of perils covered under Clauses (C). Seawater entering a container is one example. Minimum Clauses (C) coverage does not generally insure ordinary seawater ingress unless the loss results from a specified covered peril. The actual wording of the policy and the cause of the damage determine whether the insurer must pay.
CIF also causes confusion about when risk passes. A buyer purchasing goods CIF Los Angeles assumes the seller bears the risk until the shipment reaches California. Under the standard rule, risk generally passes when the goods are loaded aboard the vessel at the port of shipment, even though the seller pays for freight and insurance to the destination port. For ordinary container shipments where the seller arranges transportation, we generally prefer CPT or CIP over CIF. If the seller is also obtaining insurance, CIP is usually the better starting point because its default coverage is broader. We still ask to see the actual policy and check that it covers the losses the products are most likely to suffer. The ICC Academy explains the insurance differences in its comparison of CIF and CIP.
DDP Shipping: When the Supplier Promises to Handle Everything
Under DDP (Delivered Duty Paid), the seller agrees to arrange transportation, handle import clearance, pay the applicable duties, and deliver the goods to the named destination. The arrangement appeals to American companies without experienced logistics departments, and it can leave them dependent on a Chinese supplier's promises about customs compliance. DDP makes the seller contractually responsible for import clearance and payment of applicable duties and taxes, but that agreement does not override U.S. customs law, determine by itself who is legally the importer of record, or protect a buyer that knowingly participates in customs fraud.
The Fabric Importer That Paid Its Supplier and Then Paid the Duties
In Buyer Beware: The Hidden Risks of Unpaid Tariffs Under DDP, we discussed several matters involving companies that contacted our firm after their DDP arrangements went wrong. One involved an American fabric importer that purchased substantial shipments from a new Chinese supplier under DDP terms. When the goods arrived, Customs flagged them for unpaid tariffs. The Chinese supplier stopped responding, and the goods remained in a bonded warehouse while storage charges accumulated. The American buyer eventually paid the duties itself to obtain the inventory and fulfill its customer orders. It then came to our firm hoping to recover the money from the Chinese supplier. We advised against pursuing the claim. The supplier was a small company with no apparent meaningful assets outside China, and the buyer lacked contractual protections that would have made recovery easier. The likely recovery did not justify the expense and difficulty of litigation. The buyer had paid its supplier a price that included the duties and then paid those duties again to secure the goods.
The same article discusses two other matters involving misclassified fashion goods and undervalued industrial machinery. Buyers should also understand that allowing someone else to handle importation does not eliminate their own potential customs-law exposure. In April 2026, Boise Cascade pleaded guilty to a felony Lacey Act violation involving illegally imported Chinese plywood and received a $6,382,000 fine and five years of probation. It was not a DDP case, but it illustrates the serious consequences buyers can face when they knowingly participate in illegal importation or deliberately ignore the warning signs. We discuss the case in DDP Shipping Risks: What Boise Cascade's Guilty Plea Means for U.S. Buyers. Before accepting DDP, we want to know who will act as importer of record, who will submit customs declarations, and how duties will be calculated and paid. We also want the buyer to have access to the relevant customs documentation. An unusually low delivered price on goods subject to substantial tariffs deserves close examination before the buyer places its order.
When the Purchase Order and Invoice Specify Different Incoterms
Some of the most expensive disputes we have handled began with inconsistent documents. The buyer issued a purchase order specifying one Incoterm, the supplier responded with an invoice specifying another, and neither party resolved the discrepancy before shipment. When the transaction went wrong, the parties disagreed over which document controlled. The answer depended on their agreement, their conduct, and the applicable law. Neither a buyer's purchase order nor a supplier's later invoice automatically controls every transaction.
The EXW/CIF Dispute That Cost $150,000 in Legal Fees
One of our clients became involved in litigation after using a purchase order that specified EXW terms while the supplier's invoice specified CIF. Neither party reconciled the inconsistency before shipment. When the goods were damaged in transit, each side relied on its preferred document to argue that the other bore responsibility. Our client prevailed, but the litigation lasted approximately two years and cost around $150,000 in legal fees. A dispute like that likely would have been avoided by getting the purchase order and invoice to agree before shipment. These disagreements are often difficult to explain to clients afterward, because the buyer's purchasing department has one set of documents, the supplier's sales department has another, and the freight forwarder has been operating under whichever instructions it received.
The $3 Million Russia-China Shipment Dispute
We also represented a mid-sized American company that contracted with a Fortune 500 supplier to purchase food products for delivery to Russia. During the transaction, the United States imposed sanctions in response to Russia's invasion of Ukraine, and our client diverted the goods to China. The diversion resulted in a loss of approximately $3 million. Our client's purchase order specified FOB, placing transportation risk on our client once the goods were loaded aboard the vessel. The supplier's invoice specified DAP, under which the supplier bore that risk until the goods reached the named destination, ready for unloading. DAP also left import clearance with our client. Each party had chosen an Incoterm that worked against its own interests, and neither had resolved the inconsistency before the shipment was diverted.
We argued that the supplier's invoice controlled because it came after the purchase order and had not been rejected. We also considered how a jury would view a dispute between our smaller American client and a much larger multinational company. The parties eventually settled by essentially splitting the difference. The Incoterms discrepancy mattered to the dispute, though those terms did not independently determine who bore the economic consequences of sanctions or the decision to divert the shipment. Those questions required analysis of the broader agreement and applicable law. A contract involving international shipments needs to address those risks expressly, especially when the destination is a politically sensitive market.
What Incoterms Do Not Cover
Incoterms do not determine when ownership passes, establish payment obligations, provide remedies for breach of contract, or resolve the effects of sanctions, force majeure, and many other legal problems. The ICC explains these limitations in its guidance on Incoterms and commercial contracts. Risk of loss and product acceptance are separate questions. A buyer can assume the risk of accidental damage during transportation while retaining the right to reject defective products when they arrive. A seller can retain legal title after transportation risk has passed to the buyer, and payment can occur before or after either event. We have encountered factories that confuse transportation risk with responsibility for manufacturing defects. A factory that ships FCA and then argues that the buyer must accept improperly manufactured products because the risk passed when the carrier collected the goods is confusing two different obligations. The Incoterm establishes who bears the risk of accidental loss or damage during transportation, and it does not excuse the factory from manufacturing products that meet the contract's specifications.
We see similar problems when transactions involve warehousing or services beyond the original sale. In Reviewing China Contracts, we described a contract from a Chinese warehouse operator that failed to specify basic transportation and handling responsibilities. The English and Chinese versions also differed materially. One provision in the Chinese text required our client to insure goods stored in the warehouse, but that obligation was missing from the English translation. Someone reviewing only the English version would have missed it. Our clients regularly tell us their Chinese factories have promised to deliver within 30 days. We put that deadline into the manufacturing agreement, along with a provision requiring payment of an agreed amount for each day the factory is late. The factory reviews the contract and announces that it actually needs 45 days. Sometimes it needs 60. The original promise was easy to make when there were no consequences for missing it.
We discuss this in How to Get Your China Product Deliveries on Time. Incoterms establish how and where delivery occurs under the chosen rule, but they do not create a production schedule or determine the remedies for late performance. The manufacturing agreement needs to establish when the production clock begins, what counts as timely delivery, and what happens if the factory fails to perform. A promise to deliver FCA at the Chinese factory is different from a promise to deliver DAP to an American warehouse. A buyer purchasing products for a particular selling season needs to know which obligation the factory has undertaken.
Putting the Right Incoterm in Your Contract
When we draft an international manufacturing agreement, we start by finding out how the transaction will operate. We want to know who selects the carrier, who arranges transportation from the factory to the port, who handles export clearance, where the goods will be handed over, and which party can best manage each stage. For ordinary containerized shipments where the buyer controls freight, FCA is often our starting point. If the seller arranges transportation, CPT or CIP may be preferable. If the seller is to bear transportation risk until the goods reach the buyer's destination, we consider an appropriate D term. We do not let a supplier's standard quotation decide these matters without examining the consequences.
Specify the Delivery Point and Incoterms Edition
A recurring mistake is using an Incoterm without identifying the relevant location precisely enough. A contract that merely says "FOB Shanghai" can leave questions about the intended port facilities or loading arrangements. For FCA, the contract should identify the factory, terminal, or other agreed delivery point. For an ordinary factory pickup, we would use language along these lines: FCA [full factory address], [city], China, Incoterms 2020. We once advised a client selling through a Chinese distributor that did not yet know which Chinese port would receive future shipments. We recommended against quoting CIF prices because our client had no reliable way to calculate those future freight costs. Instead, we advised using FCA or, where appropriate, EXW, with the distributor choosing the destination port and bearing the associated transportation costs. We also recommended pricing future orders under an export price list that could be updated periodically, rather than locking prices into the long-term distribution agreement. We discuss the issue in Selling Products in China: The Legal and Distribution Guide.
The contract should also identify the applicable edition of Incoterms. For new contracts, we generally recommend Incoterms 2020 unless there is a sound reason to use an earlier version. American commercial law also uses FOB terminology, and UCC Section 2-319 defines FOB shipment and destination terms differently from the ICC's maritime FOB rule. The parties should identify which rules they intend to use.
A related issue arises under the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG). A sale of goods between an American company and a Chinese company will ordinarily fall under the CISG if the transaction is within its scope and the parties have not excluded it. Choosing the law of an American state does not necessarily exclude the Convention. If the parties intend to exclude it, the contract should say so expressly.
Make the Documents Match the Transaction
The manufacturing agreement, purchase orders, invoices, and shipping instructions should reflect the same arrangement. When multiple documents govern the transaction, the contract should establish which controls if they conflict. Companies selling through distributors also need to coordinate their manufacturing and distribution contracts. When a China manufacturing agreement transfers risk to the American company as the goods leave the factory, but the company's American distribution agreement makes it responsible until the goods reach the distributor's warehouse, the company bears the transportation risk between those two points. That arrangement works if the company understands it and carries appropriate insurance for the gap. We discuss this in Why Your U.S. Distributor Agreement and China Manufacturing Contract Will Eventually Collide.
Incoterms also matter when calculating customs value. Under U.S. rules, qualifying international freight and insurance charges generally can be excluded from the customs value of imported goods, but the importer must be able to document the actual charges. Foreign inland freight can require additional proof. In an October 2025 Customs and Border Protection ruling, an importer purchasing Chinese food products under CIF terms was denied freight and insurance deductions because its documentation did not adequately establish the amounts and their treatment. In After the Wall Street Journal Calls: Why Tariff Reduction Is Not a One-Hour Fix, we discuss situations where an importer describes its purchases as EXW but the supplier actually arranges and pays for freight, then invoices the buyer for reimbursement. That discrepancy can affect whether transportation expenses are included in the customs value of the goods. Writing EXW on an invoice does not make a transaction EXW if the parties are operating under different arrangements. Customs valuation depends on the actual transaction and supporting records.
We also review how the shipping provisions work with payment milestones, inspection rights, product acceptance, delivery deadlines, and remedies for defective or late goods. Where insurance is required, we want to see when coverage begins and ends and who is insured. If the parties negotiate a different risk allocation from the standard Incoterm, the contract should identify that change rather than leave it for a court or arbitrator to reconstruct. The factory's pro forma invoice often arrives before the manufacturing agreement is signed. It is tempting to treat its shipping terms as a detail to be sorted out later, particularly when both sides are eager to begin production. We would rather resolve those terms while the parties are still negotiating and can change them without disrupting an order.






